Why Motivational Speakers are Not Effective

Jul 1, 2008 | Business

Hi Everyone!

To say “I am overwhelmed” by your response to starting this blog would be understating it in the extreme. Am I the only one who read every posting from you? Or did you all do that? Either way … WOW! As we get into more “life stuff” on this blog, I think our combined thoughts—available for everyone to see—will create great opportunities for us to learn and understand concepts that will make immediate differences in our lives.

Now … how can we use this blog to enrich our lives? Can we become more productive in our careers? Can we be better parents or spouses or friends? Is it possible to make more money and still have time for the quality of life we desire?

You might have noticed that on any material originating from our offices (to include books, biography, or web presence) I am never described as a “motivational speaker”. Neither do I claim any particular expertise in any specified field. How many of you know that I don’t have a college degree … ?

When I am speaking to a corporate group, I sometimes tease the audience by saying, “I appreciate being here, but I must confess that I do not really know what you do … ” It is amusing to me how nervous some of the company leaders become when I make that statement! I quickly go on to explain that while I couldn’t hope to understand the detail and skill with which they go about their daily jobs, my own “talent” lies within noticing little things that bring about seismic shifts in our lives.

Many CEO’s or leaders of major companies mistakenly believe that they can elicit better production from employees by specifically training them to do more of (or become better at) what they do. For instance, a sales organization might train in specific detail, “the steps to successful selling”. This training is usually done by someone who has enjoyed more success in sales than the people whom they are teaching.

Or an organization might bring in a “motivational speaker” to inspire the rank and file to greater levels of production …

Believe me, neither approach works long term. The only reason companies, teams, associations, or organizations do ANY of this is because of tradition (that’s what they have always done…) or they don’t have any idea what else to do!

Specific training has limited value and is virtually useless unless there is something new to learn. How many times can we hear, “The more calls you make, the more success you will have … ”

Similarly, motivation itself is highly overrated. I have never seen anyone “motivated” into winning (or even running) a marathon. One might be motivated into starting … but that’s a different story.

Think about this: If we polled society today, no one would ever say that their job/career is the most important thing in their life. The answer to that question always revolves around God or family or both. Yet corporate entities sometimes train and treat their people as if the most important thing in their lives is their career and are subsequently baffled when production and profits fail to increase.

There are four challenges I see people struggle with every day:

1) Their most significant relationship isn’t what they want it to be… (I am not saying that someone’s marriage or friendship is horrible—I am just saying it is on their mind in a somewhat negative way.)

2) Communication with their children, friends, or work partners isn’t what they want it to be… (Again, I am not saying that communication has broken down entirely, I am just saying that it is “not great”.)

3) They don’t have any idea that they can control their lives financially.

4) They are not certain that their life really matters anyway.

Listen… anytime we have employees or clients or children or friends who have any of these four challenges—or any combination thereof—they can’t possibly be trained or motivated into doing their best. Why? Because the most important part of their lives is in disarray! Simply put: Something besides their job is overriding their thoughts and reducing their effectiveness in accomplishing the task at hand.

So, you see, I don’t ever claim to save anyone’s marriage or have any particular business expertise. All I do is uncover principles which, when applied, make a drastic difference in the most important parts of our lives, allowing us to focus on our jobs and careers, ultimately generating greater results. This is what I do as a speaker, with my books, and very soon, what I hope to accomplish with this blog: Together, we will discover some little things that will make it possible to create THE LIFE YOU CHOOSE.

For now, remember that to improve your life’s bottom line (financially and in every other way), it is generally not the sales technique we need to work on—it is the salesman!

Throughout the life of this blog, you and I will find ways to dive more into specific thoughts, actions and their consequences.

In the next post, I will tell you how my life changed drastically several weeks ago …

Your friend,
Andy

Explore

  • Please…An Important Message from Andy
    Please…An Important Message from Andy

    Am I wrong to assume that you believe, as I do, that America is in big trouble? And how crazy is it that we have witnessed an extremely slow rise and fall to end up here?

    Read More »
  • Piano Days with Don Reid
    Piano Days with Don Reid

    Listen as Don shares the details about his latest book, Piano Days, and the fun story behind who discovered The Statler Brothers (and “swiped” one of their songs!). Hear Andy share one of the greatest lessons he ever learned from The Statlers, more incredible writing advice from Don…and much, much…

    Read More »
  • “It’s Benji’s Dad!” with Joe Camp
    “It’s Benji’s Dad!” with Joe Camp

    Tune in to hear Joe talk about how the Benji series came to be, the challenges he faced as a filmmaker, and what compelled him to – after being known as Benji’s dad for so many years – write The Soul of a Horse.  Listen as Andy and Joe discuss…

    Read More »
  • Uncanceled with Phil Robertson
    Uncanceled with Phil Robertson

    Tune in to hear Phil describe the aftermath of being canceled from his own hit television program, what gives him the ability to forgive those who continue in their attempts to cancel him, and the unifying message he shares with the world–one that sustains him when adversity comes. 

    Read More »
  • Saving America’s Amazon with Ben Raines
    Saving America’s Amazon with Ben Raines

    Tune in to hear Ben share why he calls Alabama’s Mobile-Tensaw Delta America’s Amazon, and the adventurous way he shares it with others. Hear he and Andy revisit the incredible story about his discovery of the Clotilda – America’s last slave ship, the update on where they are in the…

    Read More »

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This